We've been wanting to see Erin on the prowl ever since she first admitted to being a three-man woman. And after watching the majorly tense confrontation between JR and Duncan, which culminated in Duncan stroking his beard and running away, it looked like Whit's free-spirited friendzie was about to be single and fabulous once again. Only when that magical moment came, Erin was less Carrie Bradshaw from Sex and the City ... and more rom com spinster, Sandra Bullock. (That cliched "You have no messages" moment? Classic While You Were Sleeping Bullock!)

+ Think Erin made a mistake letting Duncan walk away, or does she need some alone time to figure out whether she's relationship-ready?