In the debate over whether LaToya and Swift hooked up in St. Croix, 'Toya will go to her "Real World" grave maintaining it never happened. Swift, on the other hand, seems bent on proving that his other-island affair wasn't in his head. So who do you believe?
Consider tonight's events: When Trey made a gay joke at Swift's expense, Swift looked none-too-pleased. For some reason, though, he took his frustrations out on 'Toya (at 4 a.m. while she was in a dead sleep, no less), who'd done nothing more than laugh at Trey's joke. When 'Toya confronted Swift the next day about his aggression, his anger propelled him to air their supposed dirty laundry in front of Marie and Robb, and while neither believed him, both Trey and Brandon felt he had no reason to lie. Swift said he was pissed because he expected more out of 'Toya, considering their alleged history, but 'Toya claimed her roommate was just making up stories out of spite.
+ Tell us what you think! Is 'Toya hiding from a hookup she might be ashamed of, or is Swift just looking to land some cheap shots? Take the poll!
Think LaToya and Swift really got down?
Yeah, Trey was right. LaToya's got more to lose. 60%
No way, Swift is full of hot air. 40%
Dig Remote Control? Follow us on Twitter, like, now.