We've always had a thing for guys with mustaches. The way we see it, a little facial fuzz adds a degree of rugged masculinity, and bumps everyone ('cept Yosemite Sam and Burt Reynolds) up a notch or two on the attractiveness scale. On the other hand, we're not sure we're ready to stop staring at Brody Jenner, admiring his boyish good looks and pretending he's our high school boyfriend (not so easy to do now that dude's gone out and grown himself some chin hair)!
And since we're having trouble deciding between beard or no-beard, we thought we'd put it up to a poll and let you guys decide. Do you like the Brodester better as a baby-faced man child? Or as an outdoorsy hottie who may or may not reek of Old Spice? Take a look at these before-and-after pix then tell us whether you think Brody's sexy n' scruffy -- or a total beardo!