Diddy's always been a hard man to impress and tonight he showed the Starmaker contestants a little bit of tough love. After watching the final eight perform, he had negative words for almost everyone, calling Omotayo out for his weight, dissing Liz's "old lady" dress and telling former favorites Todd and David B. they still had a long way to go.
+ Think the Bad Boy was a little harsh? Or were his critiques right on the money? Take the poll and tell us whether Diddy was tough, but fair -- or completely out of control.