The judges had no problem picking out the worst performances this week, but they couldn't agree on who rocked it best. Ultimately, they split the standout honors between Todd (who KILLED it with The All-American Rejects) and David B., who delivered big with an original song, but we wanna know what you guys think. Did one of these dudes outperform the other? Take our poll and tell us which top two finisher has the most star potential!