Take one non-committal City girl, add an adoring long-distance boyfriend ... and you've got complications. Sprinkle one flirtatious ex (who's only a cab ride away) all over the equation ... and you've got a Chrysler Building-sized conundrum. And knowing Erin's tendency to go with the flow and only assess the damage afterward, one or both of these dudes is about to get his heart broken.
Our question: Are either of these guys even good enough for Erin? Take our poll and tell us: Should Erin stick with Duncan, go back to JR or tell them both to hit the road?