Rumors of a Danity Kane breakup have plagued the group since day one, but the latest (unconfirmed) internet gossip suggests the girls won’t be disbanding so much as tinkering with their starting lineup. And while nothing’s for certain, there are a couple factors adding to this rumor’s plausibility.

First, we have the year-long whispers of tension within the ranks, supposedly stemming from Aubrey O’Day’s burgeoning solo career and/or Dawn Richard’s supposed BFF status with Diddy. And then, of course, we have the scary promos for tomorrow’s Making the Band 4 finale, which seemingly show Diddy saying buh-bye to one of the girls.

And since both hardcore DK fans and industry insiders are having trouble deciding whether this latest rumor is fact or fiction, we’ve decided to pose a different question: Would you still like Danity Kane if one of its members split? Let us know what you think, plus tell us which girls you think would be most likely to fly solo.